- Potatoes can be grown from true potato seeds (TPS) which are collected from the berries of the potato plant.
- Growing potatoes from true potato seeds is fun and you can discover some very good new varieties, but it is not as reliable as growing potatoes from tubers.
- Growing potatoes from TPS is much like growing tomatoes from seed. The plants are started indoors and then transplanted to their permanent growing location.
- Most modern potato varieties are either partly sterile, poor at forming seeds, or both. If you want to save your own TPS, you will need to start with fertile varieties or with purchased TPS, which will usually produce much more fertile varieties.
- Potato is a genetically diverse crop and the seedlings do not grow true. That means that every seedling grown from TPS is genetically unique and will produce tubers with different characteristics. Every potato plant grown from seed is a new variety.
- There are thousands of potato varieties with different colors and forms found in the Andes, but these types are a challenge to grow in North America because they do not form tubers until very late in the growing season. Andean potatoes are more readily available as TPS than as tubers.
- Some potatoes grown from true potato seeds will have higher than normal levels of glycoalkaloids, which make the potatoes bitter. You should discard any bitter varieties.
- Although true potato seeds carry much less disease than tubers, some diseases do infect seeds. For this reason, you should not import TPS from other countries.
This guide is a little bit different. I probably don’t need to tell you what a potato looks like or how it is used. You could fill a library with books written on everything from the history of the potato to laboratory techniques for the manipulation of its genome. There is no sense in rehashing topics that have been covered many times already, in depth, by people who are far more authoritative than I will ever be. So, I am not going to describe the characteristics of commercial potatoes or provide instructions for growing from tubers. Instead, I am going to focus in this guide on growing potatoes from true potato seeds (TPS) and evaluating, propagating, and maintaining what you produce. I will also discuss potato classification, because learning how to grow potatoes from true potato seeds will give you access to many more types of potatoes than you have probably been exposed to before.
Although the potato is a common crop, the types that most of us are familiar with are only part of a large range of varieties with different characteristics and uses. Almost every potato that you have ever seen at the grocery store comes primarily from progenitors of Chilean origin, a group of potatoes that were introduced to Europe in the 1800s. The ancestors of the Chilean potatoes that became the basis of the modern potato are still grown in the Andes, but they remain almost unknown in the rest of the world. Andean potatoes come in an amazing range of shapes, colors, and flavors, but the only way that most of us in North America will experience them is by growing them from true potato seeds. There are also many wild potatoes to explore, most of which are rarely available as tubers. So, growing potatoes from TPS not only allows you to breed your own varieties, but also opens up the possibility of exploring the lesser known relatives of the modern potato.
Most people have probably never thought much about how potatoes are grown. The majority of the people I know can be divided into two camps: those who think that potatoes are planted from seeds and those who believe that there is no such thing as a potato seed. In fact, potatoes are usually planted from tubers but also can produce seeds. Potato tubers for planting are often referred to as “seed tubers,” which complicates discussion. I will not use that term in the rest of this guide; wherever you see the word “seed,” I am referring exclusively to true potato seeds. In general, you will need to use the acronym “TPS” to find additional information about growing potatoes from true potato seeds, since the seed tubers are widely referred to simply as “seed”.
Potatoes belong to the family Solanaceae, the same family as the tomato, pepper, eggplant, ground cherry, tobacco, petunia, and nightshade, among many others. If you have grown tomatoes and potatoes before, you have probably noticed the similarities between the two species. Unlike tomatoes, which have small flowers and large berries, potato flowers are large and the berries are small. Although they are rarely seen in hot or dry climates, potato plants produce both flowers and berries that look like small, green (or occasionally red or purple) tomatoes. Each berry contains up to about three hundred true potato seeds, although many varieties produce much smaller amounts. These berries are sometimes called “seed balls,” although that is now a pretty dated term.
The range of potato plants that even most experienced gardeners have seen is pretty small. There are roughly 50 varieties that are commonly grown in North America and they fall mostly into the category of russet baking potatoes, red and yellow boiling potatoes, and fingerlings. If you grow potatoes from true potato seeds, you will discover that potato plants can grow up to five feet tall, that some of them have partly purple foliage, that they have flowers of many different colors, and that the tubers have a range of skin and flesh colors that extends well beyond the white, yellow, and red potatoes most frequently seen in grocery stores. Growing potatoes from seed can be a source of both joy and frustration because, in addition to the wide diversity of form and flavor, you will also encounter problems that are never seen in commercial potatoes.
There are literally thousands of varieties of potatoes. The majority of them are only grown in their native region in the Andes, where there are about 3,000 extant varieties. The potatoes used in the rest of the world have emerged from a relatively narrow genetic bottleneck as a consequence of breeding them for performance in other climates and with traits suitable for industrial agriculture. So, we normally see only a very small selection of potatoes that were bred from a relatively small number of parents and that were selected to suit the sensibilities of modern agriculture.
Potatoes primarily come in two different genetic arrangements: tetraploid and diploid. Outside the Andes, diploid potatoes are virtually unknown. The potato of commerce is tetraploid, bearing four copies of each chromosome, resulting in a sort of built-in hybrid vigor that typically allows them to grow larger and yield more than diploids. Potatoes are outbreeders and experience inbreeding depression. As a result, they do not grow true from seed. Every potato plant grown from TPS is genetically different. Varieties can only be maintained by replanting the tubers. Therefore, the primary use of true potato seeds is the creation of new varieties.
Almost all commercial potatoes outside the Andes are tetraploid. Tetraploid potatoes are usually larger, higher yielding, and boring. No, that’s an exaggeration. Actually, there are a great many exciting tetraploid potatoes… mostly in the Andes. The potatoes of commerce in the rest of the world are big and uniform but not nearly as fun as the wide diversity of shapes, colors, and flavors that you can grow from true potato seeds. This is a matter of opinion, of course, but even a cursory examination of Andean and modern potatoes reveals that their selection was driven by fundamentally different values. Tetraploid potatoes are further distinguished by having the ability to self-pollinate in some cases.
Diploid potatoes are almost exclusively grown in the Andes and there are no commercial diploid varieties in North America (there are a few in Europe and Japan). Even in the Andes, they comprise a fairly small percentage of varieties; most Andean potatoes are tetraploids. Diploid potatoes are small and usually have lower yields than tetraploids, but they compensate for this with a great diversity of skin and flesh colors. Many of them have flavor that is superior to commercial potatoes. In addition to the tubers, the plants are typically smaller and have narrow foliage compared to tetraploids. The seeds are usually smaller than those of tetraploids as well (Simmonds 1963). Diploid potatoes are self-incompatible, so every variety is a hybrid.
Potatoes have two growth habits: determinate and indeterminate, which are largely synonymous with early and late maturities, respectively. Determinate potatoes usually have early to mid-season maturities. They grow to a certain size, set tubers, and then senesce uniformly. Indeterminate potatoes will continue to grow for as long as conditions allow, producing very large plants and, in some cases, very large harvests of tubers. This is not a useful trait for big agriculture, since it makes it difficult to time the harvest. Where indeterminate varieties and big agriculture intersect, as is the case with the classic variety ‘Russet Burbank’, the solution usually involves killing the crop with herbicide in order to harvest while weather is still favorable. Indeterminacy can be a very good trait for small growers who are not reliant on mechanical harvesting. One important thing to note about indeterminacy is that it does not mean that potatoes continue to produce more tubers as you hill them higher. This is a persistent myth. Indeterminacy means that the plant is able to continue growing larger and collecting more sunlight to form tubers, but the number of stolons is not significantly different.
Potato taxonomists have divided up domesticated potatoes under a number of different schemes over the years. This is good insofar as it shows the progress of our understanding of the evolutionary relationships between varieties. It is, however, rather confusing for the amateur potato breeder, because the potato literature is filled with references to outdated systems.
The two main classification systems that are used in potato literature over the past fifty years divide the different potato phenotypes into either nine species and two subspecies or eight cultivar groups underneath the single species, S. tuberosum. Although these systems are still commonly used, modern genetic analysis has made them both obsolete. Unfortunately, nobody is going to go back and revise all of the books, research, genebank identifications, and other material that relies upon the previous classification systems. They may not even be used consistently in modern work; for example, while the USDA genebank generally uses the most recent taxonomy, the International Potato Center (CIP), still uses the old species designations in many cases. You need to be aware of both the historical and modern systems of classification for now.
S. tuberosum subsp. tuberosum or S. tuberosum, Tuberosum group.
Tetraploid. The modern potato, which probably originated in coastal Chile as a result of selection among andigena type potatoes for long day tuberization. This group of potatoes was introduced to Europe about 150 years after andigena types and was bred intensively following the destruction of many of the existing andigena cultivars by late blight.
S. tuberosum subsp. andigenum or S. tuberosum, Andigenum group.
Tetraploid, originating probably from a natural hybridization between a stenotomum potato and a wild relative (Grun 1990). Andigena potatoes are the immediate ancestor of Chilean potatoes. Their main distinction from modern and Chilean varieties is that they have short day tuberization. Size and yield are generally smaller than modern potatoes. They are considerably more diverse though, with a wide range of colors and shapes. Taste is often superior to that of modern potatoes. Unfortunately, many of them are quite vulnerable to late blight, because the late blight pathogen was not present during their evolution. This was the group of potatoes originally introduced to Europe, before late blight developed and made it infeasible to continue growing them.
S. stenotomum or S. tuberosum, Stenotomum group.
Stenotomum potatoes are diploids. Unlike the Phureja group of diploids, they have dormancy. They are grown at higher elevations in the Andes and many have some frost resistance (NRC 1989). Stenotomum tubers tend to be long, often with an irregular surface, and colors are primarily white, red, or purple. Frost resistance and dormancy make this group of potatoes particularly interesting for breeding for short season climates. Stenotomum includes what was previously known as S. goniocalyx, commonly known as papa amarilla, a group of small potatoes with yellow skin and flesh, known for their particularly rich flavor. Stenotomum is thought to be the earliest of the domesticated potatoes, from which all other Andean domesticated potatoes descended.
S. phureja subsp. phureja or S. tuberosum, Phureja group.
Phureja potatoes are diploids. Few have any significant dormancy; very shortly after the tubers mature, they begin to sprout again. This is a useful trait in the warmer eastern side of the Andes, where they are grown between 7000 and 8500 feet. Because frosts are rare at these elevations, there can be two or three crops per year. Lack of dormancy is generally an unsuitable trait for growing in North America, where the tubers can be exhausted in storage before the weather is suitable for planting, although there are techniques that can be used to grow such potatoes successfully, particularly in relatively mild climates like the maritime Pacific Northwest.
Phureja potatoes are usually small, two to three inches (5 to 7.5 cm) in diameter at the most, but they are colorful, often have unusual shapes and deep eyes, and have excellent flavor. They also often have superior disease resistance. They can be hybridized (with a low success rate, but one still manageable by amateurs) with tetraploid Solanum tuberosum, usually producing tetraploid progeny (Grun 1990). The tetraploid progeny sometimes have good dormancy. They are grown at lower altitudes in the Andes and do not exhibit frost tolerance. Phureja potatoes are thought to have been bred from stenotomum potatoes, with the goal of eliminating dormancy (NRC 1989). Hundreds of varieties exist in the Andes.
As noted earlier, modern genetic analysis is wiping away all of the historical categories. I introduced them first because there is such a huge body of literature that uses them that you will probably continue to find them more useful than modern classification for a long time to come. Modern classification lumps the four categories from the previous section into two cultivar groups under S. tuberosum: Andigenum and Chilotanum. There are also additional species recognized for the higher polyploids, but I’m sticking to the basics in this guide. See Spooner (2007) for a more detailed treatment.
This is the group of Andean potatoes and includes everything that was previously included in the Andigena, Stenotomum, and Phureja groups. This includes diploid and tetraploid varieties. Most are short day tuberizers.
For more information about Andean potatoes, check out our Andean potato guide.
This is the group of tetraploid potatoes of Chilean origin. This includes most modern potatoes, although modern potatoes are now commonly hybridized with more distant relatives. Most of them are day neutral types.
There are other groups of cultivated potatoes and roughly 100 edible and non-edible wild relatives, but those are outside the scope of this guide.
There is quite a bit more to potato ploidy than I am covering here. Understanding the nuts and bolts will become a lot more important to you as you do more intentional breeding and produce your own true potato seeds from controlled crosses. But, knowledge must be built one step at a time and this section will get you through the basics.
Diploid potatoes are more straightforward for breeding because they have only two copies of each gene, called alleles. This makes it much easier to determine the genotypes of varieties and to plan crosses more effectively. Despite that, the vast majority of varieties in the world, and almost all of the modern varieties, are tetraploid. Tetraploids have four alleles of each gene, which doubles the genetic complexity and makes it much more difficult to predict inheritance of traits. If we were encountering the crop for the first time today, with the benefits of all our accumulated knowledge, we might choose to adopt diploid potatoes as the foundation of further breeding efforts, but the introduction of the potato to Europe was not planned. It happened gradually, from a few separate introductions, and most of the early breeding was done by people whom we would now consider amateurs. They had little knowledge of the potato because that sort of knowledge simply wasn’t available. They had to learn from experience.
There are other reasons as well. As a rule, tetraploid potatoes are higher yielding and have larger tubers. While there is some overlap, the yield potential in tetraploids will probably always be greater than that of diploids. Throughout the plant kingdom, polyploids (any level of ploidy greater than diploid) usually are larger than diploids. Polyploids have more copies of each gene, so they make more proteins. This causes them to have larger cells and the larger cells tend to translate into a larger overall plant with a greater yield.
Another significant problem is that all of the diploids are short day tuberizers; in North America, they don’t begin to form tubers until fall. This would be a serious problem for potato growing in most areas of the country. There is some variability in this trait to select from and varieties that tuberize at longer day lengths have been produced over time from short day stock. Still, this would be a major hurdle for breeding to overcome. Most diploids also have no dormancy, which is a problem similar in scale to the short day problem. There aren’t many climates in North America where potatoes without dormancy will overwinter easily.
There is a small group of diploids, previously classified as S. stenotomum that have dormancy. They would only need to be selected for longer day length tuberization in order to have a breeding population suitable for higher latitude growing. It isn’t clear why more work hasn’t been done with these varieties. One problem is that they are not particularly diverse, with only a small number of extant varieties. Working with stenotomum type potatoes to select varieties that can grow well in North America would probably be a good project for amateur and freelance breeders. Once varieties are selected that tuberize in longer days, they could then be crossed with the more diverse pool of low dormancy diploids for further development.
You have two possible routes to starting your adventure in growing potatoes from seed: you can grow plants from tubers and use them to produce TPS or you can obtain seeds to start with. If you do not have an existing collection of tubers to work with, I recommend starting with true seeds, as it will save you time, have a far lower risk of introducing potato diseases, and should give you much greater genetic diversity to work with. You should also consider that many modern varieties are male sterile. They will set seed if pollinated by another variety, but they will also transmit the male sterility to the next generation. This is another good reason to start from seeds that have been produced by a population that does not include male sterile varieties.
Growing potatoes from TPS adds work and complexity to what is normally one of the simpler plants to grow in the garden. Toss a few tubers in the ground and a few weeks later, you should have thriving potato plants. Growing potatoes from TPS is similar to growing tomatoes from seed, which is a task that many people outsource by buying starts. So, why go to the effort?
As a Supplement to Tubers
Have you ever thought that you would like a potato a little bit different than those available for planting? Maybe you need resistance to a particular pest or disease. Maybe you like the flavor of a variety but wish that it produced a bit better. Maybe you would like to experiment with colors and sizes that aren’t commonly available. If so, you could consider breeding your own potatoes from true potato seeds. Once you find a potato that you like, you can just keep replanting the tubers every year. Over time, you can build a collection of your own varieties, unique to your garden. When you begin to grow potatoes from TPS and selecting the ones that you like best, you are taking the first steps toward breeding your own varieties.
Instead of Tubers
Do you have problems with potato diseases, but hate buying certified tubers? Do you like to experiment more than you value a predictable harvest? Would you rather have a bowl full of tubers of all shapes, sizes, and colors, rather than uniform potatoes that look just like what you can buy at the store? If so, you might forget about planting from tubers entirely and just grow from true potato seeds every year.
Although I now keep a lot of tubers for continued breeding, for several years, I grew potatoes only from seed. It was a surprisingly successful experiment! We never lacked for potatoes to eat. Many of the plants were low yielding, but many were also high yielding, so it balanced out. Production was about the same as I achieved growing commercial potatoes from tubers. I rarely found inedible, bitter potatoes, although there were a few that tasted pretty bad. It should be noted that I live in a very potato friendly climate, so results may not be so good elsewhere, but I definitely think that this is an experiment worth trying.
Potato plants flower and set seed most readily in cool, humid conditions. This is a commonality of Andean crops, which originated in cool, tropical highlands. In potato, higher temperatures reduce or completely suppress flowering and pollen production. The viability of whatever pollen that is produced is also reduced at higher temperatures. Some varieties will set seed even in hot, dry conditions, but the widest range of varieties will flower and fruit in maritime climates.
In many climates, it will be much easier to start with TPS produced by someone growing in more favorable conditions. Once you have seedlings with a wide range of characteristics, you are likely to find a few that set seed in your climate more readily than the commercial varieties. You can then save seeds from those plants and you will be on your way to a better adapted potato for your location.
One of the great breakthroughs that allowed the potato to become one of the world’s staple crops was the development of varieties that are day length neutral. In the Andes, almost all potatoes are short day tuberizers; they don’t begin to form tubers when there are more than roughly twelve hours of daylight. This is not an impediment near the equator, where day length changes very little over the course of the year, but at higher latitudes, short day varieties don’t begin to form tubers until the end of September, by which time frosts are approaching in many areas.
When you grow commercial varieties of potato, you are guaranteed that they will be day neutral, but when you grow potatoes from true potato seeds, particularly if they are Andean varieties, it is very likely that they will turn out to be short day plants. In colder climates with a short growing season, you will probably want to discard all of the short day plants, since the odds of producing tubers are low. However, in climates with a long growing season, short day plants can actually turn out to be good performers. They often produce very large vines and, although they form tubers late in the growing season, they can leverage that huge plant to form heavy yields quickly.
Flowering is also influenced by day length. In general, long days are most suitable for potato flowering. True potato seeds also have stronger dormancy when produced under long day conditions (Taylorson 1982). For this reason, TPS produced at higher latitudes is best stored for a year or more before sowing, although there are ways to improve germination in dormant seed, discussed below.
True potato seeds are typically long lived, retaining good germination for at least fifteen years at 70° F (20 C), showing almost no reduction in germinability (Barker 1980). By reducing storage temperature to 40° F (5C) or less, they may retain acceptable germination for 50 years or more. Potato seeds can even survive in the field to germinate as volunteers for seven years or more (Lawson 1983), something worth considering if you will be producing a lot of seed.
Towill (1983) summarized data gathered at the USDA Potato Introduction Station for both domesticated and wild potatoes. Stored at a temperature of 1 to 3 C (about 34 to 37 F) after drying to 5% humidity, the seeds of domesticated species showed very little loss of germination over 27 years. Wild potatoes were less consistent, but retained good germination over similarly long periods with a few exceptions: S. berthaultii dropped from 80% to 4% over 23 years, S. andreanum from 90% to 12% over 12 years, and S. fendleri dropped as much as 100% to 28% over 21 years. Some species showed increases in germination over similar periods.
Exposing true potato seeds to high temperatures has significant effects on both dormancy and lifespan. Pallais (1995) found that seeds stored at high temperature and higher moisture content lost dormancy within four months and germinated at 88%. However, when dormancy is broken by exposure to high temperature, seed life is reduced. High temperature storage may be useful when there is a requirement to sow seed shortly after it is collected, but if there is a requirement to store seed for longer periods, it should be stored dry and cold.
- Sow true potato seeds six to eight weeks before your last frost (at the earliest) or intended date for planting out.
- Press the seeds into the surface of your potting soil and cover by about 1/8 of an inch.
- Water thoroughly once with room temperature water and do not water again until the soil begins to dry out.
- Keep the temperature at about 65° F constant or alternate between 65° F day and 55° F night.
- Keep seedlings under strong lights for 14 to 16 hours per day. Don’t forget that lights will increase the temperature.
True potato seed is a fickle creature. Some germinate easily, in a short amount of time and with good uniformity. With others, you will be certain that the seeds were duds, only to have a seedling pop up a month later, and then another in a couple of weeks, followed by three or four in a flush, and then a long waiting period again. In some cases, the reason is genetic. In others, it is environmental. True potato seeds are covered in germination inhibitors and if the seeds are insufficiently cleaned, they can remain to interfere with your seed starting. Also, these substances break down over time, so fresher TPS often has more irregular germination than old seed.
True potato seed that is less than one year old is considered to be dormant and germination is more difficult than in older, non-dormant seed. Some varieties like conditions a little warmer and some a little colder. Some are just less domesticated and are holding onto the risk hedging strategy that is present in most seeds of wild plants; spreading germination over a long period ensures that at least some will grow under favorable conditions. Pallais (1995) found that dormant seed will germinate readily at 50 to 68 degrees F (10 to 20 C), but will only germinate at warmer temperatures once dormancy has been broken.
Start true potato seeds indoors about six to eight weeks before you will be ready to plant them. If your growing conditions will be on the warmer side, six weeks should be fine and, if conditions will be on the cooler side, eight weeks is better. In that time, you should be able to produce seedlings that are about five inches (12.5 cm) tall and ready for transplant to the field. You really don’t need to rush to start TPS in most climates. If you start eight weeks before your average last frost, then some years will be colder and you will struggle to keep the seedlings in good condition until they can be transplanted. Unless you are in a very short season climate or one with scorching summers, you might as well give yourself a few weeks of leeway. I think that starting too early is one of the most common mistakes made when growing potatoes from seed. Once the seedlings are eight weeks old, you need to move fairly quickly to get them transplanted to the field as any with early maturities will begin to form tubers and further growth is limited once tuberization begins. Sowing as soon as frosts end may be important in hot summer climates, where you want the plants to be able to grow in cooler spring weather. In a cool to moderate summer climate, you can start potatoes from TPS as late as August and still produce a crop.
Press seeds into the surface of your medium (any soil or soilless medium is fine) and then cover just barely with a little bit of fine material. Potato seed germination is inhibited by light, so it is important to cover them, but the seedlings are fairly weak and cannot push their way through a thick layer of soil. Keep the surface of the soil moist until you see seedlings beginning to emerge. At that point, you have two choices: you can prick out the seedlings and transfer them to another container or you can continue to grow them in the original containers. If you don’t transfer them, withhold water, allowing the surface of the soil to dry out before watering again. I prefer the first method because the conditions necessary for good germination and the conditions necessary for maintaining seedling health aren’t exactly the same. Most people don’t do this and still have good results, particularly if they perform two transplants (see below). Seedlings will usually perform best at temperatures between 60 and 70° F (16 to 20 C), but will tolerate a wider temperature range as they become established.
Keep seedlings under strong light. About five days after sowing, I put them under lights, so that the seedlings will have light as soon as they emerge. Standard fluorescent tubes must be kept about two to four inches (5 to 10 cm) off the tops of potato seedlings to provide sufficient light (the more bulbs per fixture, the higher they should be). Lights will increase the temperature around the plants, so you should keep a thermometer near the seedlings to check how much difference the lights make. Adjust your room temperature accordingly. More intense lights can be kept further from the seedlings. We use 8 bulb, 54 watt T5 fluorescents, hung about 24 inches above the tops of the seedlings. Spacing for high intensity LED fixtures should be similar. The daily lighting period should be at least 14 hours; I prefer to use 16 hours on and 8 hours off, in most cases. In general, you can’t give potato seedlings too much light, but you can easily give them too much heat if you aren’t paying attention.
True potato seeds can also be started outdoors under natural light. In northern regions with cool springs, this is best done a little later in the year. We start TPS outdoors beginning in June. While you can direct sow, the total rate of seedling germination and survival is usually pretty low. Seeds are better started in pots or seedling beds. A raised seedling bed will provide a little more soil warmth early on, which aids in germination. You can also run a heater cable in a seedling bed, which will help if you are trying for an early batch of seedlings in a chilly climate.
You can potentially improve germination of true potato seeds in the following ways:
- Imbibition (soaking the seeds)
- Temperature alternation
- Treating with gibberellic acid (GA3)
- Supplementing with activated charcoal
For improved germination, you can soak seeds in room temperature water for 24 hours before sowing. This ensures that the seeds receive enough water to imbibe properly and at a temperature where they have the necessary metabolic activity to do so. In soil, the seeds may not receive enough water, particularly if they are surface sown. Lower temperatures also reduce the rate at which the seeds take in water, so the soil may dry out before they have imbibed enough.
The optimum constant temperature for true potato seed germination is about 60° F (16 C) (Lam 1968, Gallagher 1984, others). Alternation between 12 hours of 65° F (18 C) and 12 hours of 55° F (13 C) is more effective at germinating dormant seed (Lam 1968), although some wild species germinate poorly when the temperature is not constant (Bamberg 2018). At 60° F, true potato seeds of most domesticated varieties begin to germinate within ten days. They may germinate uniformly, with most of the seedlings emerging by the twentieth day, or you might get one seedling each week for months, known as “trickle germination.” If the ambient temperature is significantly lower than the range above, I recommend starting TPS over a thermostat controlled heating pad in order to achieve uniform temperature. In general, the more uniform the daytime and nighttime temperatures, the more uniform the germination is. When the temperature drops significantly at night, germination can be slowed substantially.
Germination can also be greatly increased by exposing the seeds to gibberellic acid (GA3). A 24 hour soaking in 50 ppm GA3 can produce more than 90% germination at 60° F (Lam 1968). A 24 hour soaking in 2000 ppm GA3 will break the strongest dormancy (Simmonds 1963) and this level is recommended by the USDA Potato Introduction Station (Bamberg 2017b). A 50 ppm solution is 50 mg of GA3 dissolved in 1 liter of water. For small batches of seed, 10 mg dissolved in 1 cup of water is about 50 ppm. (Typically, you would first dissolve the GA3 in about 10 ml of rubbing alcohol and then mix that into the water, because GA3 is much more soluble in alcohol than water.)
Adding activated charcoal to the growing medium may also improve germination. Bamberg (1986) also found that it substantially improved and hastened germination in domesticated true potato seeds, but had a relatively small effect on germination in wild potato species. The study was done in petri dishes, so it isn’t clear what level of supplementation might be effective when growing in soil.
I wouldn’t hesitate to use GA3 or activated charcoal to germinate irreplaceable seed, but I think it is worth considering whether regular use of supplements might introduce dependence. When breeding plants, I try to avoid using techniques that I don’t intend to employ permanently.
The First Year
You can treat seedling potato plants like any other potato, growing them out to full size plants and taking a normal harvest. To do this, you will need to undergo at least one properly timed transplant. Because seedling potato plants don’t have a tuber to draw on for reserve energy, they tend to be a bit more delicate than tuber grown plants. You will need to pay close attention and make sure that they get enough water and don’t have too much weed competition. Once the plants are well established, they are as tough as any other potato plant. Many people claim that it is not possible to get a full yield from seedling potatoes, but I think this is the result of insufficient hardening of the seedlings, mistimed transplant, or difficult growing conditions. It took some practice, but I routinely get full yields from first year plants.
Alternatively, you can grow your TPS seedlings in small pots for the first year. The pots will limit the size of the plants and help to encourage earlier tuberization unless they are short day types. Pots require less attention to hardening and transplant timing, so they are more forgiving. You will get a small yield of mini-tubers which can be planted out in the field directly the following year with much less care than is required for seedling plants. This is a technique that I use often, particularly if I am searching for particular traits in the tubers. This allows the space-efficient screening of large numbers of seedlings. On the other hand, if you aren’t looking for easily identifiable traits in the tubers, you then have to wait an extra year before making your first selection.
You can transplant once or twice. There are advantages and disadvantages to both methods. Whichever way you choose, allow the soil to dry out in between waterings enough that it begins to shrink away from the walls of the container, but not so much that the seedlings wilt. Water from the bottom. You should water just enough that all of it is taken up into the containers. Don’t let the plants sit in a puddle. Managing wetness is crucial in avoiding damping off. A little water stress causes potatoes to form more extensive root systems, which is a big benefit when you transplant to the field (Wagner 2011).
Doing an initial transplant is optional, but can produce superior results and usually makes your life easier when transplanting to the field. Prick out the seedlings and plant into small cells in flats. This forces the seedlings to produce compact root balls (Wagner 2011). Although you can also transplant them into undivided flats, or containers of any sort, cells avoid the problems of spreading, tangled roots that result if you sow in open flats.
You can also transplant into a seedling bed if you have a greenhouse or live in a suitably mild climate. This is my preference. I plant seedlings in a bed with a six inch spacing in all directions. The root ball is not nearly as compact as those of plants grown in containers, but because the plants are not entangled, you can easily pull out the whole, fist sized root balls for transplanting to the field.
Once your seedlings are about four inches (10 cm) tall, you should begin hardening them off. You can find an unlimited number of methods for hardening off, but the main idea is that you will gradually introduce the seedlings to outdoor conditions. I like the doubling method: one hour outside the first day, two hours the next, then four, eight, and sixteen hours. After that, the plants are ready for transplant.
If you chose not to do an initial transplant, then your seedlings will be crowded together and preparing them for field transplant will take some work. This involves a lot of disentangling and usually some losses. The easiest way is to soak each container in water for about an hour and then use a hose to spray the wet soil off of the roots. You can then pull apart the seedlings and plant them in the field.
You should transplant into trenches. If you did an initial transplant, the trench needs to be only about two inches (5 cm) deep, while seedlings that are undergoing their first transplant need trenches about four inches (10 cm) deep. Plant the seedlings so that all but the top leaves are buried in the bottom of the trench. As the seedling grows, fill the trench, always keeping the top set of leaves exposed. Once the trench is full, the plant will have enough space to set a full yield of tubers. Alternatively, you can hill on top of flat ground, but make sure that your hilling spreads in at least a 12 inch (30 cm) radius around the plant. 18 inches (45 cm) is even better, since seed grown potatoes can have very long stolons. I find that a 12 inch (30 cm) in row spacing is about right for modern potato seedlings and 15 inches (37.5 cm) works better for short day Andean types, as they typically grow very large by the end of the growing season. Increase the spacing by half for dry farming.
If you have made it this far, you might also want to take a look at the top 10 beginner mistakes with true potato seeds.
As with potatoes grown from tubers, it is time to harvest after the tops die down. Once the tops die, the skins of the tubers toughen, which reduces the amount of damage that you do when digging them up. Think about how you want to evaluate them before you start harvesting. You might want to take note of things like the length of the stolons that can’t be evaluated later. Taking pictures of each plant as you harvest can be a useful record. If you want to measure yield, then you will need containers for each plant so that you can weigh them individually later.
At some point, you will need to evaluate the potatoes that you have harvested and decide which, if any, you will grow again. Some criteria are obvious: color, shape, and flavor are all fairly easy decisions. You might also want to think about maturity, dormancy, and disease resistance.
If skin and flesh color are traits that are important to you, you will need to maintain separate populations by color for the best results. Potato color genetics involve a number of genes that interact to produce the different color combinations. Blue and white are likely to overwhelm other colors in a mixed population.
Early varieties are important for both regions that have short growing seasons and regions where blight arrives in late summer. You can easily select early varieties in the seedling stage by allowing them to form tubers in the trays. The early varieties will senesce without ever being transplanted to the field and you can retain the microtubers for planting. Otherwise, they are equally easy to detect in the field as long as you start growing them early enough in the year. The first to senesce are your early varieties. Just make sure that they died back naturally and not as the result of disease!
You will want to track how many days your tubers last in storage before they begin to sprout. The dormancy period needs to be long enough that the potatoes survive until planting time.
It appears that tuber dormancy and TPS dormancy are linked (Simmonds 1964). Varieties that have little tuber dormancy will often also have little TPS dormancy and vice versa. This can be useful for high latitude potato breeders: seed lines can be sown soon after collection to evaluate for dormancy. Those that germinate quickly can be discarded under the assumption that their tubers will have poor dormancy.
The simplest approach to breeding for disease resistance is to eliminate plants that show any symptoms during the growing season. This can be very effective, but it isn’t necessarily the best place to start. A wider base of resistance genes can be formed by selecting plants in your first few breeding seasons that are vulnerable to disease, but resilient enough to survive and produce a yield. Although counterintuitive, this has the potential of producing more resistant plants in the long run (Robinson 2007). That is an extreme simplification. For more information, I recommend that you take a look at both the Amateur Potato Breeder’s Manual and Return to Resistance by Raoul Robinson.
At some point after harvest, you will be ready to give your new varieties a taste test. Some people have heard horror stories about potatoes developing toxic levels of the glycoalkaloids solanine and chaconine. Potatoes that are exposed to sunlight have increased levels of these compounds, which is why you don’t eat potatoes that have turned green. Some of the wild ancestors of the potato have much higher concentrations of these compounds even without exposure to sunlight and this trait can show up in potatoes grown from true potato seeds.
In one famous case, Lenape, a potato bred by the Wise Potato Chip Company turned out to have a level of solanine high enough to occasionally cause nausea and vomiting (Koerth-Baker 2013). Most people had no problems with it and the flavor was said to be really good. Interestingly, the bitter characteristics of the glycoalkaloids are a significant component of potato flavor, but if you go too far, the potatoes become unpleasantly bitter and unsafe to eat.
Safety is always a relative consideration. Some people eat potato tops, which are much higher in glycoalkaloids than the tubers. They appear to do so without ill effects (Phillips 1996), so there is probably considerably more tolerance for these compounds in the human diet than the estimated lethal dosage indicates. That isn’t a suggestion that you should try to find the upper limit, but will help to put the danger in context.
No domesticated potato that you grow from TPS is likely to do you serious or permanent harm when consumed in small amounts. Solanine is quite bitter, so as it rises in concentration, the odds that you will finish chewing a mouthful decline dramatically. Potatoes that taste just a little bitter may cause no reaction at all in some people, but unpleasant results in others. The typical response to a small overdose of solanine is diarrhea. A moderate overdose takes it up to nausea and vomiting. A serious overdose can result in confusion, weakness, and unconsciousness (Ruprich 2009). Symptoms may appear about four hours after consumption (Mensinga 2005).
The best practice for evaluating new varieties would seem to be starting with small amounts. I cook new varieties in the microwave and eat them plain, so that bitter flavors are not masked. I have now tasted thousands of potatoes grown from true seed, found only a few that were terribly bitter, and I have never gotten sick taste testing them. Potatoes that aren’t noticeably bitter are probably very safe, although some people are insensitive to bitter flavors. If you are one of them, you might need to get some help with your taste testing.
For more information about glycoalkaloids and safety, follow the link.
If you want to keep growing potatoes from TPS, you will need to produce more seed. There are many ways to go about this. You can plant a group of varieties that you like and allow them to open pollinate. You can perform hand pollinations between varieties. With tetraploid varieties, you can also isolate varieties that you like and let them self pollinate.
The first thing that you will need is some potato flowers. In favorable weather conditions, flowers appear two to three months after tubers or seedlings are planted out. The most favorable conditions for flowering and berry production are daytime temperatures in the 60s F and nighttime temperatures in the 50s F, accompanied by high humidity. Some varieties will flower in warmer, drier conditions, but very few will flower when daytime temperatures rise above 85° F and berries tend to drop early in warm weather. Flowering lasts about two weeks for most varieties. Certain pesticides may inhibit flowering in potato. Rio (2012) found that application of carbofuran, a nematocide, reduced flowering significantly in a number of wild potato species.
Diploid potatoes are self incompatible; they require cross pollination with another variety in order to form seed. In most cases, seed set is much better with hand pollination than relying on insect pollination.
Tetraploid potatoes are usually self compatible and will set seed that has been pollinated by their own flowers, if they have fertile pollen. That is a big “if”; most tetraploid potatoes of modern origin have pollen sterility problems. If they have sterile pollen, they require cross pollination to produce seed. But, there is another problem: the seeds collected from varieties that have sterile pollen will usually also have sterile pollen. Even when self pollination works and produces progeny with fertile pollen, the practice eventually results in inbreeding depression, which means that you are more likely to get good results by cross pollinating tetraploid potatoes than by allowing them to self pollinate. This is not always true, but the details are beyond the scope of this guide. Roughly 80% of the seeds produced by self compatible tetraploids with fertile pollen, even in mixed plantings, are self pollinated. In order to maximize hybrid TPS production, you must emasculate flowers and hand pollinate.
When hand pollinating, you have the choice of performing open pollination or controlled pollination. Open pollination is the easier choice. You simply collect pollen from one set of flowers and transfer it to another. One easy way to go about this is to use an electric toothbrush to vibrate the flowers, with a small container below to catch the dislodged pollen. You can then use a small brush to paint the pollen onto the flowers that you want to pollinate, or if you have collected a lot of pollen, simply dip the flowers into the container. Because you have not blocked other pollinators from reaching the flower, it is likely that the pollination you perform won’t be the only one. The flower might have been pollinated before you get to it and it might be pollinated again after. This is the nature of open pollination. A potato berry can form several hundred seeds and each seed is the result of a separate pollination. It is rare that a single application of pollen will fully pollinate a potato berry. When hand pollinating potato flowers, repeating the pollination at least once produces significantly better seed set than a single pollination (Pallais 1985).
If you want to be certain about which variety is the pollen parent, then you need controlled pollination. Controlled pollination requires emasculating the flower: removing the stamens before their pollen matures. This procedure is beyond the scope of this guide, but you can find instructions and even videos on the Internet. In brief, you open the flower just before it would first open naturally and pluck out the stamens. This prevents self-pollination. You can then pollinate the flower and bag it to prevent access by other pollinators.
You can store the pollen that you have collected for later use, which may be important if the varieties that you wish to cross flower at different times. Dry the pollen for 24 hours in a container with silica gel desiccant and it can then be stored at refrigerator temperatures for up to two months without significant reduction in viability.
For natural pollination, bumble bees appear to be the most active pollinators in the Pacific Northwest, followed by hoverflies and other small, native bees.
It takes a minimum of six weeks for berries to mature (Simmonds 1963). The optimum time for berries to mature varies from one variety to another and I would generally prefer to not harvest berries that are less than eight weeks old. In warmer climates, berries can mature more quickly. The berries closest to the main stem produce the largest yields of seed (Almekinders 1995). These are typically also the earliest berries.
Once you have harvested mature berries, you need to extract the seeds. There are a number of ways to go about this. For small quantities, you can merely cut berries in half and squeeze out the seeds. This has the advantage of causing little damage, but would become quite tedious if you are planning on extracting hundreds or thousands of berries.
For large extractions, a blender is often used to break up the berries for about 30 seconds. This works very well, but it does cause damage to some of the seeds. The number of seeds that you will get from a blender pitcher full of berries is so large that it probably doesn’t matter, but it has been reported by the International Potato Center that a meat grinder provides a superior result, breaking up berries with very little damage to the seeds. Another study found that using a mixer with rubber beaters produced the highest percentage of germinable seed (Gallagher 1984).
Once the basic extraction is done, you have two choices for how to clean the seed: fermentation or detergent.
Fermentation for 4 days at 86° F (30° C) produces clean seed (Pallais 1985). The only problem with fermentation is that you often don’t completely get rid of the mucilage and the seeds have a tendency to clump when drying. You can speed things up by adding some dry yeast.
Detergent generally produces TPS with less mucilage, which clumps less during drying as a result. This may be an additional layer of protection against surface contamination. Potato breeder Tom Wagner recommends the following procedure: Rinse seeds in warm (90° F) water until it runs clean, without any slimy strands. Then soak for 20 minutes in a 10% solution of trisodium phosphate (TSP). TSP can be purchased at hardware stores. It is a detergent that is used for cleaning surfaces before painting, among other uses. A 10% solution can be made by adding 24 grams of TSP to a cup of water. At the end of 20 minutes, rinse the seed clean.
Once your TPS is clean, there are other treatments to consider. To eliminate surface contaminants, such as bacteria and fungi, you can bleach the seed. Soak for 10 minutes in a solution of 1 tablespoon (15 ml) of household bleach per 1 cup (237 ml) of water. You can also possibly reduce the odds of transmitting viruses by heating the seeds. I don’t usually do this, as I’m not sure about the long term effect on germinability or the efficacy for that matter. Soak the seeds in 50 C (122° F) water for 25 minutes. You will need a hot plate or other appliance that can hold a constant temperature. If the temperature goes higher than 50 C for very long, it will kill the seed. The objective here is to heat the seeds enough to kill the viruses contained within them, without harming the seed.
For additional information about extracting and cleaning potato seed, follow the link.
Although most potato growers are keenly aware that tubers can transmit bacterial, fungal, and viral diseases, most are probably not aware that disease can also be transmitted through true potato seeds. True seed is often considered to be completely disease free, but that isn’t necessarily the case.
While it can be tempting to import true potato seeds from other countries, the US currently allows TPS imports only from Canada, New Zealand, and Chile’s Region 10. You should resist the temptation to import TPS from other countries, because the consequences of doing so can be severe. I have strong opinions about the value of restricting importation of potato seed, the threat posed by diseases that could be present in the seed, and the wisdom of creating a government large enough to enforce the rules upon individual gardeners. I’m not going to share any of those opinions, because one thing overrides all of them: if you successfully import true potato seeds from a country that is restricted and the USDA finds out, they will at least come and confiscate all of your plants. They may also take the top six inches of your soil, spray your property with persistent herbicide, shut down any business that you are involved in, and possibly also assesses fines or even bring criminal charges against you. When I was still just a hobbyist, I ordered some TPS from a company in Ukraine, not realizing that it was restricted. Months later, the USDA showed up at my door unannounced, dug up the plants, and took them away to be tested and ultimately destroyed. That sort of thing will leave an impression. You might wonder how they found out. I bought the seeds through eBay and eBay provided them a list of customers who had purchased that item. So, you can bet that the USDA is watching sources of TPS that market to US customers and I’m sure that eBay is not all that they watch. Don’t take the risk. It really isn’t worth it, particularly now that there are multiple sources of diverse potato seed produced in the USA.
We probably don’t know all the diseases that can be transmitted through true potato seeds, but there are a few that we do know about:
Spindle tuber viroid is transmitted in TPS (Hunter 1969, Singh 1970) and is probably the most damaging virus that infects TPS. In one study, 100% of seeds produced by infected plants were infected (Grasmick 1986), so you can imagine how damaging this viroid could be if it were to spread. Spindle tuber viroid is present at least in the US in the upper midwest and northeast, but is not common in the west or the south. It has been eradicated from the commercial crop, which is grown from certified seed tubers, but it almost certainly persists in hobbyist collections, where many heirloom varieties have been propagated vegetatively for decades. It is not common anywhere, but if you live in the west or the south, you might want to at least quarantine any seeds that you receive from the upper midwest or northeast and look for signs of infection before growing them near your other plants. Spindle tuber viroid is the main reason why other countries don’t allow imports of true potato seeds from the United States.
In addition, the oca strain of arracacha virus B, the potato calico strain of tobacco ringspot virus (AKA potato black ringspot virus) and potato virus T can be transmitted through true potato seeds (Jones 1982). These diseases aren’t common and don’t spread easily through TPS, but great care should be exercised whenever introducing varieties of unknown provenance. The somewhat more common tobacco streak virus can transmit through tomato seed, so it can probably transmit through TPS as well.
Rhizoctonia and other fungal diseases can be carried on the exterior of the seed (Pallais 1985), a good reason to surface sterilize TPS with bleach. Early blight can be transmitted on TPS and will often manifest as damping off. Both surface sterilization and heat treatment are usually recommended to ensure that seed is clean.
There aren’t many good sources of information about growing true potato seeds on the web. Here are some of the best that I have found:
- Tom Wagner’s TaterMater Forum. It isn’t getting a lot of traffic these days, but there is a ton of information there.
- Joseph Lofthouse’s introduction to true potato seeds for modern landrace breeding.
- The Kenosha Potato Project introduction to true potato seeds.
- True potato seed guide from the International Potato Center.
- Sowing Potatoes from TPS from Daughter of the Soil. (The author, Rebsie Fairholm, also wrote a book called The Lost Art of Potato Breeding that I highly recommend.)